Types of Government

Who owns it? Who rules?

Every ideology and form of government on this shelf answers two questions. Who owns the land, the factories and the money? Who holds the power, and how can they lose it? Each page describes its subject in terms its own supporters would accept, then gives the critics.

Compare two countries MAGA, Measured

The map

Each name below is a page. Find the row for who owns the economy and the column for who rules, and the names in the cell are the systems that fit. A page whose answer differs by branch sits in the Varies by branch row or column.

Who owns it? ↓   Who rules? →No rulersVoters, with strong limits on powerOne partyOne leaderA monarchClergyThe militaryA small eliteVaries by branch
Private owners, open marketPlutocracyCapitalismLibertarianism
Private owners, regulated marketConservatismGeorgismSocial CreditDistributism
Private owners, directed by the stateFascismCorporatism
A mix of public and privateGreen PoliticsSocial Democracy
Workers and communitiesDemocratic SocialismCooperativesCommunes and Utopias
The stateCommunismTotalitarianismKleptocracyTechnocracy
Held in common, no stateAnarchism
Varies by branchDemocracyLiberalismMonarchyTheocracyStratocracyOligarchyAristocracyAuthoritarianismPopulismNationalismNativismMeritocracySocialism

Who owns it: market economies

Systems built on private ownership, from the open market to the regulated one.

Capitalism

An economic system in which private owners hold most businesses, and markets, not a central plan, mostly decide what is made, at what price, and who earns what.

Owns: Private owners, open marketRules: Varies by branch

Liberalism

A political tradition that puts individual rights, consent of the governed and limited government first, and holds that political authority must be justified.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: Voters, with strong limits on power

Libertarianism

A philosophy that treats individual freedom as the highest political value, and holds that the state should be as small as possible or, for some, absent.

Owns: Private owners, open marketRules: Varies by branch

Conservatism

A tradition that values inherited institutions and customs, distrusts sweeping change, and holds that society changes best slowly and with respect for what came before.

Owns: Private owners, regulated marketRules: Voters, with strong limits on power

Social Democracy

A political and economic approach that keeps a market economy and private ownership, and uses democratic government, taxes and unions to fund a large welfare state and limit inequality.

Owns: A mix of public and privateRules: Voters, with strong limits on power

Distributism

An economic philosophy that wants productive property, mainly land and tools, spread among as many families as possible instead of held by a few owners or the state.

Owns: Private owners, regulated marketRules: Varies by branch

Georgism

A reform movement that would tax the rent of land, not labor or buildings, and use the revenue instead of other taxes.

Owns: Private owners, regulated marketRules: Voters, with strong limits on power

Corporatism

A system that organizes society by trade or profession, with employers and workers joined in recognized bodies that regulate their industry.

Owns: Private owners, directed by the stateRules: Varies by branch

Technocracy

A proposal that engineers and technical experts, not politicians or markets, should plan and run the economy.

Owns: The stateRules: A small elite

Social Credit

An economic doctrine that wants money distributed to consumers so people can afford what the economy produces.

Owns: Private owners, regulated marketRules: Voters, with strong limits on power

Cooperatives

Businesses owned and controlled by the people who use them or work in them, run on voluntary membership and democratic control.

Owns: Workers and communitiesRules: Voters, with strong limits on power

Fascism

An ultranationalist, authoritarian movement that puts the nation above the individual, rules through one leader and one party, and glorifies violence against its enemies.

Owns: Private owners, directed by the stateRules: One leader

Who owns it: against capitalism

Systems that put ownership with the state, the workers or the community.

Socialism

A family of ideas that put the main economic resources under public, social or collective control instead of private ownership.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: Varies by branch

Democratic Socialism

Socialism pursued through elections and civil liberties, with the major businesses to be owned democratically by the public, workers or communities instead of private owners.

Owns: Workers and communitiesRules: Voters, with strong limits on power

Communism

A goal of a classless society with common ownership and no state, and the one-party states that ruled in its name.

Owns: The stateRules: One party

Anarchism

A political philosophy that rejects rulers and compulsory authority, and holds that people can organize their own lives through voluntary cooperation.

Owns: Held in common, no stateRules: No rulers

Green Politics

A political tradition that makes protecting the natural environment central to politics and links it to social justice, grassroots democracy and nonviolence.

Owns: A mix of public and privateRules: Voters, with strong limits on power

Communes and Utopias

People who try to build a better society at small scale by living, working and owning property together, often apart from the wider world.

Owns: Workers and communitiesRules: Varies by branch

Who rules: forms of government

Forms of rule, however the economy is owned.

Democracy

A system of government in which the people rule, directly or through elected representatives, under rules that let them choose and remove their leaders.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: Voters, with strong limits on power

Monarchy

A government headed by one hereditary ruler for life, a king, queen, emperor, sultan or emir, whose power ranges from absolute to purely ceremonial.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: A monarch

Theocracy

A government in which clergy, or officials regarded as divinely guided, hold power, and religious law shapes the legal system.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: Clergy

Authoritarianism

A government in which power sits with a single leader or a small elite, with no established way to transfer executive power and few civil liberties or political rights.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: Varies by branch

Totalitarianism

A government that seeks to subordinate every part of individual life to the authority of the state, through one party, one ideology and terror.

Owns: The stateRules: One party

Oligarchy

Government by a small privileged group that tends to rule in its own interest.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: A small elite

Plutocracy

Rule by the wealthy, with wealth channeled to the ruling class through public and legal means.

Owns: Private owners, open marketRules: A small elite

Aristocracy

Government by a small privileged class, or by those presumed best qualified to rule.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: A small elite

Kleptocracy

Government by individuals who systematically use the state to enrich themselves at the public's expense.

Owns: The stateRules: A small elite

Stratocracy

Government by the military.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: The military

Meritocracy

A system in which people hold power and rewards based on ability and achievement, not background.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: Varies by branch

Populism

A movement that claims to champion ordinary people against a real or perceived elite.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: Varies by branch

Nationalism

The belief that loyalty to the nation-state outranks other loyalties.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: Varies by branch

Nativism

A stance that puts native-born or long-established residents ahead of immigrants.

Owns: Varies by branchRules: Varies by branch