Types of Government

Anarchism:
No Rulers, Every Branch, and Where It Was Tried

A philosophy of no rulers and voluntary cooperation. The founders, every branch from mutualism to crypto-anarchy, the revolutions it fought, the places it ran, and the objections.

November 21, 2026 · Emily Adams · 29 Nodules · 81 Sources
How to Read This: every glowing word opens a branch. Branches hold more glowing words. Follow any trail as deep as it goes.

What Anarchism Is

A political philosophy that rejects rulers and compulsory authority, and holds that people can organize their own lives through voluntary cooperation. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy calls it skeptical of the justification of authority and power. The word comes from the Greek anarkhos, “without a ruler,” and the American Heritage Dictionary gives two senses: the absence of any form of political authority, and political disorder and confusion. Anarchists mean the first.

Pierre-Joseph Proudhon was the first to use the name for his own view, in 1840, Peter Kropotkin wrote in 1910, after French revolutionaries had hurled it as abuse. The gap between is the oldest quarrel over the word, and it shapes how the movement is described.

The Stanford Encyclopedia sorts the varieties into political, religious, applied and post-anarchist. The applied forms include anarcha-feminism, queer, green, Black and Indigenous anarchism, anarcho-veganism and anarcho-primitivism.

Who Owns It: Held in Common or by Individuals, Never by the State

Anarchists agree that the state should own nothing, and disagree on what should. wrote in 1840 that “property is robbery,” and in the same book separated possession, which he defended, from property. anarcho-communism puts instruments of labor in common possession, under the slogan “well-being for all.”

such as Benjamin Tucker kept private ownership and markets, in a stateless form that combined Proudhon with the English thinker Herbert Spencer. Bakunin held the middle: “liberty without socialism is privilege, injustice; and that socialism without liberty is slavery and brutality.”

The line between private ownership and anarchism is itself disputed. The Center for a Stateless Society defends market anarchism, and the Anarchist FAQ argues that anarcho-capitalism is not anarchism at all.

Who Rules: No One, by Design

The aim is a society that, in Kropotkin’s words, is “conceived without government,” its harmony kept by “free agreements.” Decisions are made by voluntary association, federation and consensus. Anarchists do not reject expertise, only imposed command. wrote: “In the matter of boots, I refer to the authority of the bootmaker.”

Critics say order without rulers returns as unofficial rule. Jo Freeman’s essay, , argued “there is no such thing as a structureless group.” Friedrich Engels said in 1872 that “a revolution is certainly the most authoritarian thing there is,” a point that fed the .

What Anarchists Believe

The diagnosis is that authority must justify itself, and rarely can. Noam Chomsky puts the burden of proof on authority. Max Stirner wrote that “every state is a despotism,” and Proudhon called government of man by man “illegitimate and absurd.” William Godwin, whom the Stanford Encyclopedia calls the founder of philosophical anarchism, built the case in 1793 (). Philosophers separate a priori anarchism, Robert Paul Wolff’s 1970 argument that authority conflicts with autonomy, from the philosophical anarchism of A. John Simmons, which doubts that any state’s authority is justified.

On human nature, Kropotkin argued that “mutual aid is as much a law of animal life as mutual struggle” (). Thomas Hobbes held that without a sovereign life is “solitary, poore, nasty, brutish, and short.” The remedy is : building the alternative now. On violence the movement splits: taught nonviolence, while Goldman and Malatesta argued over how much force is justified.

Anarchists also differ on method. Bakunin backed the Paris Commune, syndicalists organized through unions, and direct actionists, in de Cleyre’s phrase, asserted their rights boldly. Food Not Bombs and community fridges are examples of what David Graeber called prefigurative politics: building the new arrangement inside the old one.

What Anarchists Value

In rank order: liberty first, understood as freedom from imposed command, not only from the state; then solidarity and mutual aid; equality of condition, which individualists define differently from communists; and voluntary association. Emma Goldman called anarchism “the philosophy of a new social order based on liberty unrestricted by man-made law.”

What it will trade away is the guarantee of order by force. The movement has refused to give up its internal disagreement. Voltairine de Cleyre wrote in 1901 that the schools of anarchism once refused to recognize one another, and later said she called herself simply “Anarchist.”

Critics say the ranking leaves no way to settle a dispute when two people claim liberty against each other. Anarchists answer, with Proudhon, that government of man by man is illegitimate, and with Malatesta that free agreements can replace it. Nozick argued from the opposite side that a minimal state would arise on its own.

A Short History of Anarchism

Kropotkin names Zeno the Stoic as a precursor. The modern line begins with Godwin in 1793, Proudhon’s 1840 book and Stirner’s The Ego and Its Own (1844). In the First International, the split with Marx defined the movement, and in 1871 Bakunin backed .

The decades from 1880 to 1930 were its peak and its crackdown. Tucker’s Liberty began in 1881 and the Industrial Workers of the World in 1905. After the 1901 assassination of President McKinley by a man of anarchist sentiments, the United States passed , and the deported Goldman. Italian anarchists were executed in 1927. Anarchists fought in the Russian and Spanish revolutions. Occupy brought the method back in 2011.

In Ukraine, Nestor Makhno’s army held about a third of the country in 1919 and was crushed by the Bolsheviks by late 1920. In Spain, the anarchist CNT union ran collectives in Catalonia from 1936, then joined the Republican government in November 1936 and lost ground after the May Days of 1937. Both movements ended in defeat.

The Branches of Anarchism

Voltairine de Cleyre counted four schools in 1901: Individualists, Mutualists, Communists and Socialists. Mutualism follows Proudhon, collectivism Bakunin, and communism Kropotkin. The Christian, individualist and market currents sit beside them. organizes through unions and the Industrial Workers of the World.

The 20th century added more. and queer anarchism extended the argument to gender. quarreled over lifestyle and class. draws on the Black radical tradition. are the market wing, whose place in the family is disputed.

Where It Has Been Tried

No anarchist society has governed a large state for long. The cases are short-lived, local or partial. (1918 to 1921) and (1936 to 1939) are the two largest, and both were ended by force. in northern Syria, of Chiapas and in Copenhagen are living or recent experiments, and a fought for independence.

Scholars also point to that were not self-described anarchist: medieval Iceland, Somalia after 1991 and the hill peoples of southeast Asia. Whether they count is argued.

What the cases share is how they ended. Makhno’s army and the Catalan collectives were destroyed or absorbed by larger forces, Rojava was folded into a state in 2026, and Christiania’s own residents removed its drug market in 2024. Medieval Iceland, which lasted over three hundred years in Friedman’s account, did not call itself anarchist.

The Case for It and the Case Against It

The Claim

“Anarchy means chaos and violence.”

The Reply, Ready to Paste

The American Heritage Dictionary lists two senses: absence of political authority, and disorder. Malatesta wrote in 1891 that the second sense comes from “the prejudice that government must be a necessity.” Some anarchists used violence, as President McKinley’s assassin did in 1901, but Tolstoy built a nonviolent anarchism, and Goldman and Malatesta argued over proportion.

Defenders say authority needs justification and that voluntary cooperation can work, pointing to cooperatives, unions and the commons. Elinor Ostrom’s 2009 Nobel Prize in economics was for her analysis of economic governance, especially the commons. Kropotkin’s mutual aid is the philosophical core.

The Stanford Encyclopedia lists five : that it means chaos, evolves back into a state, is utopian, is incoherent, or is toothless. Engels said revolution needs authority, and the Spanish record shows trade-offs even for anarchists in office. Defenders reply that existing states are not immaculately conceived either, as Rothbard put it.

What Anarchism Is Not

The Claim

“Anarchism and libertarianism are the same thing.”

The Reply, Ready to Paste

In American usage “libertarian” often means right-libertarian. Rothbard said libertarians were once “a polite word for left-wing anarchists” and that his side captured it. The Stanford Encyclopedia says individualist anarchism includes some libertarianism, while Chomsky says anarcho-capitalism would produce tyranny. The family is disputed from inside.

It is not the same as disorder, and it is not the same as libertarianism, though the two overlap. Murray Rothbard wrote that “libertarians” had been “a polite word for left-wing anarchists” before his side captured the word. Left anarchists such as Chomsky say anarcho-capitalism would produce “tyranny and oppression.”

It is also not Marxism. Marx wanted a transitional state; anarchists wanted none, and the two camps split in the First International. And it is not nihilism: the Stanford Encyclopedia treats it as a family of political philosophies with its own literature.

Anarchism Today

Anarchism now shows up mostly as method. in 2011 used consensus and refused leadership. Food Not Bombs, founded in 1980, runs without formal leaders. Mutual-aid networks and community fridges revived during the pandemic. The Catholic Worker movement still calls for “a decentralized society.”

The state-scale experiments are mixed. In 2026 the Kurdish administration in northern Syria was folded into the Syrian state, and the Zapatistas reorganized their autonomous governments in 2023. David Graeber, the anthropologist and anarchist who helped shape Occupy, died in 2020 at 59.

The market wing has its own present. Timothy May’s manifesto, which declared the specter of crypto anarchy, imagined anonymous interaction that would alter the state’s ability to tax and control, and the Stanford Encyclopedia notes that cryptocurrencies are arguably outside state economies. Whether that counts as anarchism is the old quarrel again.

The Trail Map

Every nodule in one place. Choose one and the page opens the trail that leads to it.

Sources

Every source cited in the branches, in alphabetical order.

  1. Al Jazeera, David Graeber, Occupy Wall Street’s Anarchist Roots (2011)
  2. American Heritage Dictionary, Anarchy
  3. Catholic Worker Movement, Aims and Means
  4. Chomsky.info, Noam Chomsky Interview (1996)
  5. Cornell Legal Information Institute, 8 U.S. Code 1424
  6. Cornell Legal Information Institute, Turner v. Williams, 194 U.S. 279 (1904)
  7. David Friedman, Private Creation and Enforcement of Law: Iceland
  8. El Universal, What Are the GAL (2023)
  9. Encyclopedia of Ukraine, Makhno, Nestor
  10. Euronews, Copenhagen Residents Dismantle Christiania’s Drug Market (2024)
  11. Famous Trials, Douglas Linder, The Sacco and Vanzetti Trial
  12. FBI, The Palmer Raids
  13. FBI, Wall Street Bombing 1920
  14. Food Not Bombs, Our Story
  15. Freetown Christiania, Official Site
  16. Government Publishing Office, Immigration Act of 1903, 32 Stat. 1213
  17. Human Rights Watch, Under Kurdish Rule (2014)
  18. Jo Freeman, The Tyranny of Structurelessness
  19. Marxists Internet Archive, Bakunin, Federalism, Socialism, Anti-Theologism
  20. Marxists Internet Archive, Bakunin, God and the State, Chapter 2
  21. Marxists Internet Archive, Bakunin, Statism and Anarchy (1873)
  22. Marxists Internet Archive, Bakunin, The Paris Commune and the Idea of the State (1871)
  23. Marxists Internet Archive, Engels, On Authority (1872)
  24. Marxists Internet Archive, Goldman, Anarchism: What It Really Stands For
  25. Marxists Internet Archive, Kropotkin, Anarchism, Encyclopaedia Britannica (1910)
  26. Marxists Internet Archive, Malatesta, Anarchy (1891)
  27. Marxists Internet Archive, Proudhon, What Is Property?, Chapter 1 (1840)
  28. Marxists Internet Archive, Proudhon, What Is Property?, Chapter 5 (1840)
  29. Middle East Institute, Syria’s SDF Integration (2026)
  30. Miller Center, Death of the President (McKinley)
  31. Mises Institute, Rothbard, The Betrayal of the American Right
  32. Nobel Prize, Elinor Ostrom, Facts (2009)
  33. NPR, Occupy Wall Street: From a Blog Post to a Movement (2011)
  34. Orwell, Homage to Catalonia (1938)
  35. Peter Leeson, Better Off Stateless: Somalia, Journal of Comparative Economics (2007)
  36. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Anarchism (2025)
  37. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Hobbes’s Moral and Political Philosophy
  38. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Libertarianism (2025)
  39. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Max Stirner (2024)
  40. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Nozick’s Political Philosophy
  41. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, William Godwin (2024)
  42. SUNY Press, Dongyoun Hwang, Anarchism in Korea (2016)
  43. The Anarchist Library, Ackelsberg, Separate and Equal
  44. The Anarchist Library, An Anarchist FAQ
  45. The Anarchist Library, Anderson and Samudzi, The Anarchism of Blackness
  46. The Anarchist Library, Arshinov, History of the Makhnovist Movement
  47. The Anarchist Library, Baschet, The Reorganization of Zapatista Autonomy
  48. The Anarchist Library, Bey, T.A.Z.
  49. The Anarchist Library, Black, Anarchy After Leftism
  50. The Anarchist Library, Bookchin, Social Anarchism or Lifestyle Anarchism
  51. The Anarchist Library, C4SS Market Anarchism FAQ
  52. The Anarchist Library, Daring et al., Queering Anarchism
  53. The Anarchist Library, de Cleyre, Direct Action
  54. The Anarchist Library, Dejacque, On the Human Being, Male and Female
  55. The Anarchist Library, Dolgoff, The Anarchist Collectives
  56. The Anarchist Library, D’Alessandro, The Forgotten Anarchist Commune in Manchuria
  57. The Anarchist Library, Ervin, Anarchism and the Black Revolution
  58. The Anarchist Library, Goldman, My Disillusionment in Russia
  59. The Anarchist Library, Konkin, New Libertarian Manifesto
  60. The Anarchist Library, Kornegger, Anarchism: The Feminist Connection
  61. The Anarchist Library, Kropotkin, Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution
  62. The Anarchist Library, Kropotkin, The Conquest of Bread
  63. The Anarchist Library, Nettlau, The St. Imier Congress of the International
  64. The Anarchist Library, Rocker, Anarcho-Syndicalism
  65. The Anarchist Library, Spooner, No Treason
  66. The Anarchist Library, Tolstoy, The Kingdom of God Is Within You
  67. The Anarchist Library, Zerzan, Future Primitive
  68. The Conversation, Massachusetts Executed Two Italian Immigrants 90 Years Ago (2017)
  69. The Conversation, Mutual Aid: Can Community Fridges Bring Anarchist Politics to the Mainstream? (2021)
  70. The Conversation, This Anarchist Thinker Helps Explain Why We Feel So Driven to Help Each Other (2020)
  71. The Guardian, David Graeber Dies Aged 59 (2020)
  72. The Guardian, David Graeber, Why Is the World Ignoring the Revolutionary Kurds in Syria? (2014)
  73. The Guardian, Murray Bookchin Obituary (2006)
  74. The Guardian, Vatican Beatifies Spanish Civil War Dead (2007)
  75. The Guardian, Vive la Commune: The Working-Class Insurrection That Shook the World (2021)
  76. The National, SDF Integration into Syrian State Marks Milestone (2026)
  77. Timothy C. May, The Crypto Anarchist Manifesto
  78. UNESCO World Heritage Centre, Thingvellir
  79. University of California Press, Michael Seidman, Workers Against Work (1991)
  80. University of Washington, IWW History Project
  81. Yale University Press, James C. Scott, The Art of Not Being Governed

Image Credits

  1. Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (1809 to 1865), photographed by Nadar. Nadar. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  2. Peter Kropotkin, painted by Leonid Pasternak. Leonid Pasternak. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  3. Voltairine de Cleyre, American anarchist writer. M. Herbert Bridle. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  4. Leo Tolstoy, photographed by Sergei Prokudin-Gorskii. Sergei Prokudin-Gorskii. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  5. Emma Goldman, anarchist writer and speaker. Takuma Kajiwara. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  6. Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti, Italian anarchists executed in 1927. Unknown author Unknown author. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  7. Nestor Makhno in 1919. Unknown author Unknown author. Public domain. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
  8. Entrance to Freetown Christiania, Copenhagen. Neptuul. CC BY-SA 4.0. Wikimedia Commons. Resized.
0 / 29 Explored Trail Map